Select Location

Remember When Sweet Shop – Pensacola

Considered a hidden gem, Remember When Sweet Shop “The Affordable Candy Store” offers award winning homemade fudge, candy, glazed nuts, jam and a whole lot more.

About us

In the spring of 2014 we started making fudge and on Saturdays selling it from a booth at the Palafox Market in downtown Pensacola, FL.  As our little business grew, we found ourselves making more and more fudge and expanding the number of flavors that we made.  We listened as our customers made suggestions to expand our line of sweet treats, and we started to realize that we were out growing our cottage food operation.  In March of 2015 we entered a contest because the proceeds were going to a good cause.  We didn’t expect much, but were very happy when we were awarded first place in the candy division. At that point we knew that we were onto something good, so we took the leap and decided to open a full fledged candy store.  After a lot of hard work we opened Remember When Sweet Shop in the fall of 2015 so our goodies would be available 6 days a week.
Our product line has grown to include Glazed Nuts, Retro Candy, Chocolates, Truffles, Vintage Soda plus Flavored Honey Butters, All Natural Jams and Salsa.  AND….. we still continue to grow!

Remember When Sweet Shop
Sample product list


We make 50+ flavors of fudge and we offer 12 flavors of fudge with daily changes

Chocolate Bark

Caramel Toffee
Spicy Dark Chocolate Pistachio
Chocolate Mint
Chocolate Pretzel
Root Beer
Peach                                                                                                                                                              Chocolate Peanut Brittle
Cookies and Cream
Triple Berry & Nut

Specialty Candy

Chocolate Covered Blueberries
Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes
Chocolate Nonpareils
Chocolate & Caramel Coconut Haystacks
Pecan Turtles
Chocolate Espresso Beans
Assorted Truffles
and more

Nuts & Brittle

Cinnamon Glazed Almonds
Cinnamon Glazed Pecans
Praline Pecans
Salted Caramel Cashews
Peanut Brittle
Almond Brittle
Cashew Brittle
Pecan Brittle
Honey Nut Sesame Crunch


Retro & Bulk Candy
Retro "Penny" Style Candy
Bottled Retro Soda
Salt Water Taffy


All Natural Jam, Salsa & Gourmet Dip Mix

Flavored Honey Butter

Cinnamon Honey Butter
Cranberry Orange Pecan Honey Butter
Dark Chocolate Pecan Honey Butter
Peach Amaretto Pecan Honey Butter
Praline Pecan Honey Butter
Salted Caramel Pecan Honey Butter
Toffee Pecan Honey Butter

Place Categories: Candy Shops, Cuisine, Featured Restaurant and Sweet Shops

Reviews are closed.

Report this?

Claim Listing

What is the claim process?

Captcha Verification
captcha image